Unmarried couples’ property rights in England and Wales: why ownership, family loans and inheritance wishes need to be recorded clearly.
A couple live together for 45 years, raise three children and share a substantial family home. One partner adopts the other’s surname. Marriage is apparently discussed but never takes place.
When the relationship eventually ends, the home, now reportedly worth £6 million, is still registered in the sole name of the partner who owned it before the relationship began.
The result is not an orderly division of property. It is a High Court dispute in which the parties are asking a judge to reconstruct conversations, intentions and financial arrangements stretching back to the 1970s.
The proceedings concern Dennis and Coral Read. As reported by Today’s Wills and Probate, Coral claims that she was repeatedly promised an equal interest in Woodlands House in Surrey and says she devoted her life and some of her own money to the property. Dennis denies that she has any beneficial interest and maintains that she made no contribution to its acquisition.
There is also a separate dispute over £876,000. Dennis says it was a loan intended to be passed to their son to discharge mortgages. Coral denies signing the alleged loan agreement and says the money was a gift for their son.
The hearing was reported as adjourned while the court considers whether Dennis, now aged 88, is medically fit to give evidence and be cross-examined. The reporting cited here records no final findings on the competing claims, which remain for the court to determine.
This is therefore not an article about which party should win.
It is about how 45 years of family life can still produce profound legal uncertainty when intentions are never properly documented.
Does living together create a common law marriage?
There is no such thing as a “common law marriage” in England and Wales.
Living together for decades, raising children or presenting yourselves publicly as husband and wife does not give a couple the same legal rights as marriage or civil partnership. GOV.UK explains the distinction.
When married couples divorce, the family court has broad powers to examine their resources and reach a financial settlement. Unmarried couples do not have an equivalent statutory framework.
Their property disputes are generally determined using property and trust law. The court is principally concerned with ownership and beneficial interests, not simply with what might appear fair after a long relationship.
Where the family home is registered in one partner’s name, the legal starting point is that the registered owner also owns the entire beneficial interest.
The other partner must establish why the true beneficial ownership is different.
“They promised me the house” is the beginning of a dispute, not an estate plan
A person whose name is not on the title may, depending upon the evidence, attempt to establish an interest through a common-intention constructive trust or proprietary estoppel.
That can require the court to examine:
what was said between the parties;
whether a promise or shared intention existed;
whether the claimant relied upon it;
whether they acted to their detriment;
financial contributions to the property;
expenditure on improvements;
responsibility for household and family arrangements; and
the parties’ wider course of conduct over many years.
The burden rests on the person arguing that beneficial ownership differs from the registered legal ownership. Courts have repeatedly recognised how difficult it can be to reconstruct intentions after relationships have broken down and memories have become contested. The Supreme Court discusses the different starting points for sole and joint ownership in Jones v Kernott.
Even a general intention that someone should eventually receive a property does not necessarily give them an immediate beneficial interest in it. The legal effect depends upon the precise promise, the surrounding circumstances, reliance and evidence.
Litigation may eventually establish the parties’ rights. But by then, certainty has already been lost.
The £876,000 question: loan or gift?
The disagreement over the separate £876,000 payment presents another familiar estate planning problem.
One person says:
“It was a loan.”
The other says:
“It was a gift.”
If the terms were not recorded clearly at the time, a court may later need to decide:
who received the money;
for whose benefit it was paid;
whether repayment was required;
when repayment became due;
whether interest applied;
whether security was intended;
whether any document was genuinely signed; and
what the parties’ conduct suggests they understood.
That distinction can affect ownership, tax, estate administration and what ultimately passes to beneficiaries.
Substantial family payments should not be left with the label “we all understood what it was”. Families often do understand, until circumstances change, relationships deteriorate, somebody dies or capacity becomes an issue.
Memory is not a reliable substitute for documentation.
The iTrustLaw view
The true lesson from this case is not simply that unmarried couples should make Wills.
A Will is essential, but it only governs what a person actually owns at death. It does not, by itself, resolve an existing disagreement about who beneficially owns the family home.
Effective planning must align:
legal title;
beneficial ownership;
lifetime promises;
Wills;
trusts;
loans and gifts;
succession intentions; and
incapacity arrangements.
If one partner is intended to own half of a property, that should be formally recorded.
If they are intended to live in the property for life but not own it outright, the right of occupation and responsibility for expenses should be documented.
If the property is ultimately intended for children, the arrangements should explain what protection the surviving partner will receive and when the children become entitled.
If money is advanced to a partner or child, a proper loan agreement should state whether it is repayable and on what terms.
If the payment is genuinely a gift, that should also be recorded so that nobody later has to guess.
What should cohabiting couples put in place?
Depending on their circumstances, couples should consider:
1. A declaration of trust
This records the beneficial ownership of the property, including each person’s share and how sale proceeds will be divided.
2. A cohabitation agreement
This can document the couple’s wider financial arrangements, including responsibility for mortgages, household expenses, improvements and what should happen following separation.
3. Coordinated Wills
Each partner’s Will should reflect the property ownership arrangements and explain what happens on death. An unmarried partner does not automatically inherit under the intestacy rules merely because the relationship was long or committed.
4. Properly documented loans and gifts
Significant payments between family members should be recorded when they are made, not several years later when recollections have diverged.
5. Lasting Powers of Attorney
A partner does not automatically have authority to manage the other’s finances or make health and welfare decisions if capacity is lost. Lasting Powers of Attorney allow you to plan who may act, subject to the relevant rules. GOV.UK explains the two types of LPA.
6. Regular planning reviews
Arrangements should be reviewed when property is purchased, substantial money changes hands, children or grandchildren are born, relationships alter, health deteriorates or succession intentions change.
Planning is not pessimistic
Some couples avoid documenting their arrangements because it feels unromantic or unnecessarily formal.
The opposite is usually true.
Clear planning protects both partners. It records the agreement while the relationship is cooperative and while both people can explain their wishes and make informed decisions.
It also protects their children from inheriting uncertainty, competing claims and avoidable disputes.
The iTrustLaw position is straightforward:
If a promise matters, document it. If ownership is shared, record it. If money is lent, define it. If a partner is to be protected, build that protection into the legal planning.
After 45 years together, nobody should need a High Court trial to discover whether the family home was ever truly theirs.
Frequently asked questions
Does living together for many years give you half of your partner’s house?
No automatic half share arises simply from living together. In England and Wales, the legal title, any declaration of trust and evidence supporting a beneficial interest matter. The outcome depends on the circumstances.
Does a Will settle an existing dispute about who owns the home?
No. A Will deals with the estate a person owns at death. It does not, by itself, determine a disputed beneficial interest in property. Ownership arrangements and Wills need to work together.
Should a family loan or gift be put in writing?
Recording a significant payment when it is made helps show whether it is a gift or loan. For a loan, the agreement should explain who owes the money and the repayment terms.
Speak to iTrustLaw about reviewing your estate planning if your family circumstances, property ownership or wishes have changed.
About the author
James Berkeley — Senior Counsel, iTrustLaw
James brings together business, legal and financial knowledge to help individuals and families across the UK plan for the future. His approach reflects iTrustLaw’s commitment to supporting clients “from cradle to grave”.
This article provides general information about England and Wales and does not constitute legal, tax or financial advice. The claims described in the reported proceedings remain disputed and have not been determined in the reporting cited. Case reporting checked on 18 November 2026.